Place and Movement
Getting around and getting in is where a city's promises meet a person's day. A paratransit van that comes an hour late, a curb with no ramp, a Medicaid ride that never arrives, a wheelchair waiting six weeks for a part: each is a small failure that nobody counts, so nobody fixes. This chapter applies the catalog's ideas to movement and access, then maps twelve territories with current facts, specific things to build, who is already doing them, scores, and three sizes of first step.
Index: Worth Building
Movement is a relationship before it is a trip
The things that get people where they need to go already have names. The dispatcher who knows which rider needs a lift and which needs five extra minutes. The volunteer driver who waits through the appointment. The neighbor who reports the broken elevator. The daughter who books the ride and sits by the phone. The dominant technology in transportation is pointed at a solo rider in a driverless car, and it treats each of these people as a cost. This chapter points the same technology at the rider and the people who move with them, and at the record of what the system actually did.
| Scene | The default path | What we could build instead |
|---|---|---|
| The paratransit pickup | A thirty-minute window, a van that misses it, a complaint line with a long hold, and no public record of any of it. | The rider's own trip log, consented and pooled, shows missed trips by agency and month; the dispatcher keeps the judgment and loses the paperwork. |
| The sidewalk | A 200-page transition plan nobody reads, an inventory on one staff member's laptop, and a ramp built when someone sues. | Residents label missing ramps on a shared map, the plan is readable by block, and the public sees what was promised and what was poured. |
| The ride to the doctor | A Medicaid broker's call center, a no-show, a rescheduled appointment, and a grievance form in the broker's language. | The appointment has a care circle; the no-show is logged once by the rider and becomes a county fact the state must answer. |
| The rural county | A demand-response service nobody can find in a trip planner, a neighboring county on different software, and a microtransit pilot that costs more per ride than a taxi. | Small agencies publish rides in one open format, a plain-language page says what rides exist, and the dispatcher's local knowledge is the asset. |
| The robotaxi | A driverless fleet with no wheelchair-accessible vehicle and no timeline for one, in a city whose law requires one on request. | Accessible vehicles are measured by wait time in every market, riders carry an access profile any operator must honor, and the standard is public. |
| The wheelchair repair | A chair out of service for six weeks while a supplier waits on authorization, with nowhere to see how long others waited. | A repair log by supplier and state, a parts finder configured by state law, and a clock the user can read. |
What each commitment means when the subject is getting around
| Commitment | In movement and access, it means | A concrete instance |
|---|---|---|
| 1 · AI is a means, not the measure | Judge a transit tool only by whether more people reach the places they need and keep the relationships they have. | A demand-response agency's dashboard leads with trips completed on time and riders it could not serve, and treats vehicle utilization as a footnote. |
| 2 · Keep people in charge | Legible service rules, a human dispatcher when a trip is denied or rerouted, and a rider who can take their eligibility, trip history, and access profile elsewhere. | A rider who moves to the next county carries their eligibility file and profile, and the new agency reads them instead of starting over. |
| 3 · Build capability, not dependence | Riders and families learn the rules of eligibility, appeal, and service, so the second application needs no helper. | A decision letter reader that names the 21-day clock, the appeal step, and the kind of eligibility granted, in the agency's own words. |
| 4 · Make drift visible | Surface the slow changes. Missed trips creeping up, hold times lengthening, repair times stretching, routes quietly cut. | "Your agency's missed-trip rate has doubled in six months." "Your county's median wheelchair repair took six weeks this quarter." |
| 5 · Design for groups | The rider and the people who travel with or for them are the user. So are the dispatcher and driver as a pair, the volunteer program, and the town. | A care circle around a standing dialysis trip: the rider, a daughter, the clinic, and the dispatcher, each seeing only what they need. |
| 6 · Protect the friction that matters | Remove the forms, the fax, and the hold music. Keep the dispatcher's call, the driver's hand at the door, and the volunteer's conversation. | A volunteer driver program whose scheduling and reporting run themselves, so the saved hour goes to the waiting room with the rider. |
| 7 · Refuse inevitability | Driverless fleets without ramps, microtransit sold as a bus replacement, and brokers with no public record are choices. Name them and point to working alternatives. | A small company runs wheelchair-accessible autonomous shuttles in a rural Minnesota town. New York requires every new taxi to be accessible. The alternative exists. |
The three questions, applied
| Thing | More capable or more dependent? | Closer to each other or to the system? | See, steer, and leave? |
|---|---|---|---|
| A driverless ride-hail fleet with no accessible vehicle | Dependent, and excluded if you use a wheelchair | Alone in a car, closer to the platform | No public wait-time data; no profile portability |
| A crowd-labeled sidewalk map | Capable: residents learn what a compliant ramp is | Closer: neighbors and public works share one map | Open data, open code |
| A Medicaid broker's call center | Dependent; the rider cannot see the record | Closer to the broker | Grievance in the broker's words; no exit |
| A volunteer driver program | Capable: a town carries its own elders | Closer to a neighbor | Fully, though records rarely travel |
| An agency's paratransit booking app | Capable, if it explains the rules | Usually closer to the agency than the family | Trip history rarely exportable |
| A repair log under a right-to-repair law | Capable: users and independent shops can act | Closer: a shared record across users | Fully, if users hold the data |
Where to push in movement and access
| Place to push | What it means | In movement and access |
|---|---|---|
| Paradigm | AI as a means | Transportation as access to people and places; the trip comes after the person and the destination. A missed dialysis ride is a health event, and a missed school bus is a civil-rights event. |
| Goals and metrics | Capability, trust, connection | Trips completed in the window, denials and missed trips, hold time, repair time, rides with a known driver, appointments kept, and whether riders can explain their eligibility. |
| Information flows | Make drift visible; the most practical lever | There is no national dataset on paratransit on-time performance, denials, or hold times. Broker no-shows live in audit reports years late. Repair times are self-reported by suppliers. All of it is buildable from the rider's side. |
| Rules | Legibility, portability, interoperability, exit | Open data standards for sidewalks, stations, and demand-response rides; accessibility deadlines for public websites and apps in 2027 and 2028; right-to-repair laws for wheelchairs; accessible-vehicle requirements for taxis and robotaxis; a rider's right to their own trip record. |
| Self-organization | Cooperatives, civic groups | Centers for independent living, riders' unions, volunteer driver programs, transit worker unions, rural agencies pooling software, and a member-owned cooperative that holds riders' trip data. |
The disability rights movement is one of the clearest cases in American history of people acting together to change a rule. In April 1977, protesters occupied a federal building in San Francisco for weeks until the government signed the Section 504 regulations on 28 April. On 12 March 1990, more than a thousand people marched to the Capitol and about sixty left their wheelchairs to climb the steps, and the Americans with Disabilities Act was signed on 26 July 1990. The curb ramps, lifts, and paratransit systems that followed were won by groups, and they serve everyone with a stroller or a suitcase. The movement's standing rule is that nothing about disabled people gets decided without them. That rule is a design specification. The data layer this chapter proposes belongs to the people who ride.
The map of movement and access
Scored on the catalog's rubric (shared layer nobody owns, buyer or deadline, outcome data, the three questions, fit). Each card names which of the nine reusable parts it reuses. Territory codes begin with P.
How to read a card: its score adds five judgments, each from 0 to 2 (shared layer nobody owns, buyer or deadline, outcome data, the three questions, fit), for a total out of 10.
Paratransit service quality, visible by agency and by month
The riders of about 159 million demand-response trips a year, the relatives who book and wait with them, and the dispatchers and drivers who carry them.
Why now
The American Public Transportation Association (APTA) 2025 Public Transportation Fact Book counts 6,371 demand-response systems carrying 158.7 million trips at an operating cost of about $7.4 billion, of which about $3.8 billion is purchased from contractors. Demand response has recovered to 93 percent of 2019 ridership, the highest of any mode, per APTA in May 2025. There is still no standardized, current national dataset on paratransit on-time performance, trip denials, or phone hold times; the Federal Transit Administration's public compliance assessments on capacity constraints date mostly from 2000 to 2007. Where agencies publish, the numbers are stark and incomparable. New York's Access-A-Ride completed more than 1 million trips in October 2025 for the first time and reports more than 90 percent of pickups within the 20-minute window in the first half of 2025. The Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority (WMATA) says MetroAccess missed about 1.7 percent of trips in November 2025 against a goal under 0.75 percent. Alexandria, Virginia paid $58.10 per trip in fiscal 2024 and collected $0.92 in fare.
Plays
- A rider-side trip log: promised window, actual arrival, drop-off, hold time, denial, and reason, logged in ten seconds and pooled with consent into an outcome commons by agency and month.
- A records-request pipeline that pulls the monthly performance reports agencies already give their boards and normalizes them into one schema, so New York and Washington can be read on one page.
- A plain-language monthly page per agency, written for riders and councils, that says how many trips were missed, how long the phone took, and how that compares to last year.
Already there
The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) publishes Access-A-Ride drop-off on-time performance as open data back to 2016. WMATA posts MetroAccess subcommittee performance reports. The New York City Comptroller has audited the MTA's oversight of the program. No one compares agencies, and no one holds the rider's own record.
Score
Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 2 · Outcome data 2 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2
The eligibility file: applying, being assessed, and appealing
Applicants for Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) paratransit and the relatives who fill in the forms, the health professionals who sign them, and the agency staff and contractors who decide.
Why now
Most agencies require an application with certification from a licensed health care professional, and many add an in-person interview or functional assessment run by a contractor. Decisions come back as unconditional, conditional, or temporary eligibility, and conditional riders must work out trip by trip whether the bus or the van applies. Federal rules say that if an agency does not decide within 21 days of a complete application, it must provide service until it does. Every agency writes its own letter. The Department of Justice's Title II web and mobile accessibility rule reaches public entities of 50,000 or more on 26 April 2027 and smaller ones on 26 April 2028, and paratransit applications and booking apps are covered.
Plays
- A decision-letter reader: the PDF in; who, which kind of eligibility, which conditions, which dates, and the appeal step out, in plain words with a pointer to the source paragraph.
- An evidence file for the application and the appeal: what proves the claim, who holds it, request letters to clinicians in the agency's own wording, and the 21-day clock.
- A care circle around the rider, so a daughter in another state can book, see, and be reminded, and can be removed by the rider at any time.
Already there
Agency brochures and PDFs (Chicago's Regional Transportation Authority (RTA), the Utah Transit Authority (UTA), Boston's The RIDE), eligibility assessment contractors, and centers for independent living that help with applications by hand. No rider-side tool, and no record of which agencies deny most.
Score
Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 2 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2
Sidewalks, curb ramps, and the plan the city wrote
Everyone who walks or rolls, the public works staff with an inventory, and the advocates asked to read a long plan to learn when their corner gets a ramp.
Why now
The U.S. Access Board issued the Public Right-of-Way Accessibility Guidelines (PROWAG) in August 2023. The General Services Administration adopted them in July 2024, and the Department of Transportation adopted them on 18 December 2024, effective 17 January 2025, for new and altered transit stops in the public right-of-way. Agencies now need an ADA transition plan to receive federal grant funding, and cities are rewriting theirs. One inventory shows the scale: Carson City, Nevada counted 298 miles of sidewalk, 4,282 existing curb ramps, and 628 missing ones. Crowd plus AI labeling works. Project Sidewalk, from the University of Washington, is deployed in 35 cities in 8 countries, with more than 1.1 million labels across 21,380 kilometers of streets as of April 2025. In Newberg, Oregon, residents collected 17,000 labels and won two sidewalk repair programs. Pedestrian deaths are finally falling, an estimated 6,732 in 2025, down 7 percent and the third straight annual decline, yet still above 2019. Bicyclist deaths fell 6 percent to 1,103 in 2024.
Plays
- A transition-plan reader: the city's PDF in; which blocks, which ramps, which dates, and which promises out, versioned so the public can see what changed between the 2019 plan and the 2025 one.
- A standards cohort that funds small cities and their contractors to publish inventories in the OpenSidewalks schema, then wins a state department of transportation as the buyer.
- An outcome commons of promised versus poured, by city and quarter, built from records requests and from residents' labels.
Already there
Project Sidewalk (Makeability Lab, University of Washington); the Taskar Center's OpenSidewalks and the Transportation Data Equity Initiative, funded by the U.S. Department of Transportation's (USDOT) ITS4US program and covering six counties in Maryland, Oregon, and Washington; state department of transportation (DOT) ADA initiatives such as Illinois's. The plan reader and the promised-versus-built record are open.
Score
Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 2 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2
Venue, station, and route accessibility data, and one profile the rider owns
Riders who need step-free routes, working elevators, audible signals, or a quiet room, and the venues, agencies, and map companies that each hold a piece of the answer.
Why now
accessibility.cloud, run by Sozialhelden, the Berlin nonprofit behind Wheelmap, aggregates more than 2 million places from over 100 sources using the open A11yJSON format, with Foursquare and HERE among its partners. GTFS-Pathways, the station-interior extension of the General Transit Feed Specification (GTFS), is now integrated into the core specification, and GTFS-Realtime service alerts can carry elevator outages. The gap is in the data behind the standards. UnlockedMaps, a University of Washington project, scraped agency websites hourly and recorded more than 1 million elevator outage events across 2,336 stations in about 28 months, because no agency published them in a common form. The Department of Justice's 2027 and 2028 web accessibility deadlines give every public trip planner and booking app a date.
Plays
- A rider-owned access profile (step-free only, needs a ramp, needs audible announcements, travels with an attendant) stored by the rider, readable by any trip planner or operator with consent, and revocable.
- An elevator and ramp outage commons across agencies, from GTFS-Realtime feeds where they exist and from riders where they do not.
- A venue cohort: fund small venues, clinics, and polling places to publish A11yJSON records through the tools they already use.
Already there
Sozialhelden (Wheelmap, accessibility.cloud); the stewards of gtfs.org and their recommendations on service alerts; the Taskar Center's GTFS-Pathways work under ITS4US; the Chicago Transit Authority's (CTA) elevator alerts. The rider-owned profile does not exist anywhere.
Score
Shared layer 1 · Buyer or deadline 2 · Outcome data 2 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2
Demand-response data standards for small and rural agencies
Rural, tribal, and small-city agencies running dial-a-ride with a dispatcher and a spreadsheet, and the riders who cannot find them in any app.
Why now
GTFS-Flex, the extension that describes rides you have to request, was formally adopted into GTFS in 2024 and is supported by Transit, Moovit, OpenTripPlanner, and state 511 planners. A Michigan pilot planned for four agencies grew to 15 rural providers across 19 counties, and agencies in Vermont, Maine, Minnesota, and Washington publish Flex feeds. The National Rural Transit Assistance Program (National RTAP) published a report on standardized demand-response data and hosts a working group on it, and the Transactional Data Specification from the Transit Cooperative Research Program lets two agencies' systems exchange a trip. Industry sources say there are more demand-responsive routes in the country than fixed routes. The need is plain. About 5 million rural residents travel 10 miles or more for groceries, and 76 counties have no grocery store at all. The caution is plain too. The Amalgamated Transit Union, a union source, reports microtransit costing two to three times more per passenger than agencies' worst-performing bus routes, Los Angeles charged $1 for a microtransit ride that carried a $42 subsidy, and the Eno Center found no city where boardings exceeded four an hour.
Plays
- A standards cohort: fund the small dispatch tools rural agencies already use to publish GTFS-Flex and speak the Transactional Data Specification, then win state DOTs and National RTAP as buyers.
- A county rides reader built from Flex feeds: what rides exist, who may use them, how to book, in plain words and by phone as well as app.
- Keep the dispatcher. Tools that draft the manifest and the state report so the dispatcher spends the morning on the phone with riders.
Already there
National RTAP and its Demand-Response Transportation Data Specifications Working Group; Michigan's and Arizona's DOT guidance; the gtfs.org Flex documentation; rural agencies in the states named. The cohort and the reader are open.
Score
Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2
Medicaid rides: the broker, the no-show, and the record
People on Medicaid who need a ride to dialysis, chemotherapy, or a clinic, the family members who wait with them, the drivers paid by a broker, and the state agencies that pay the broker.
Why now
Modivcare, the largest non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) broker, serving 48 states and Washington, D.C. with about 23,600 employees, filed for Chapter 11 in August 2025 with a plan to cut about $1.1 billion, roughly 80 percent, of its debt, citing declining state reimbursements and coming federal Medicaid cuts. The Massachusetts State Auditor reported on 8 May 2025 that MassHealth paid about $283.3 million to its two brokers from July 2020 through June 2023 and committed to annual broker audits. The pattern is old. A Wisconsin audit covering August 2013 to June 2014 found 4,154 trips where the provider never arrived and 55,320 that were more than 15 minutes late. A Colorado state report found the Medicaid department failed to oversee its contractor and did not report incidents involving at-risk adults. MACPAC, the federal Medicaid advisory commission, counted more than $2.2 billion in fee-for-service NEMT spending in fiscal 2018, and 2.5 million beneficiaries who delayed care that year because of transportation.
Plays
- A rider-side ride log that feeds a consented outcome commons by broker, county, and month, so a no-show is a fact the state has to answer rather than a story a reporter collects years later.
- A grievance kit in each state's Medicaid wording: how to report, to whom, within what time, with an evidence file the rider and clinic both hold.
- A care circle around the standing appointment, so the clinic, the rider, and a relative see the same ride and the same miss.
Already there
State Medicaid agencies and auditors, the brokers themselves, KFF Health News's reporting, the Community Transportation Association of America's research summaries. The rider's own record is held by no one.
Score
Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 2 · Three questions 2 · Fit 1
Volunteer drivers: the ride that comes with a neighbor
Older adults and people with disabilities in places with no bus, the neighbors who drive them, and the small nonprofits that match them.
Why now
More than 800 volunteer driver programs operate in the country, according to the National Aging and Disability Transportation Center. America's Volunteer Driver Center, developed by ITNAmerica with Federal Transit Administration and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) support, aims to recruit 150,000 volunteer drivers for nonprofit providers. The federal charitable mileage deduction has been 14 cents a mile since 1997, while the business rate is 70 cents. The Volunteer Driver Tax Appreciation Act (S.1177 and H.R.1582), reintroduced in 2025, would match them. Every program runs its own scheduling and its own reporting.
Plays
- A shared back office owned by the programs: scheduling, mileage, background checks, and the funder reports, so the coordinator's time goes to matching people who will get along.
- A volunteer's own portable record, so a driver who moves takes their clearances and hours with them.
- Measure what matters: minutes of conversation and appointments kept, alongside rides, and publish by program and county.
Already there
ITNAmerica and America's Volunteer Driver Center, the National Aging and Disability Transportation Center (run by Easterseals and USAging), National RTAP's Volunteer Driver Program Toolkit. Software is bespoke and the record is local.
Score
Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 2 · Fit 1
Transit money, legible by agency: the fiscal cliff and who falls off it
Riders who learn a route is gone when the bus does not come, the councils and legislators voting on budgets they have not read, and the paratransit riders whose service area follows the fixed routes.
Why now
Philadelphia's Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA) faced a $213 million deficit for the year beginning 1 July 2025, cut service 20 percent on 24 August 2025, eliminated 32 bus routes, and raised fares 21.5 percent on 1 September. A second round on 1 January 2026 would have ended five Regional Rail lines and 50 bus routes and closed 66 stations. The state let SEPTA spend $394 million of capital repair money on operations instead, which reversed the cuts for about two years and fixed nothing. Chicago's transit agencies warned of cuts up to 40 percent before Illinois passed Senate Bill 2111; the Regional Transportation Authority now puts its 2026 gap at $200 million and its 2027 gap at $790 million without that package. In the Bay Area, operators face combined deficits above $700 million a year from 2026, and Senate Bill 63, signed 13 October 2025, puts a regional sales tax before voters in November 2026. National ridership was 85 percent of 2019 in 2024, with 7.7 billion trips. Complementary paratransit is defined around fixed routes, so a route cut can also shrink where the van must go.
Plays
- A budget reader per agency: the proposal in; which routes, which stops, which hours, which riders, and which paratransit corridors out, in plain language a council member can read before the vote.
- A service-change notice reader for riders and care circles: what changes on which date for the trips you take.
- A cliff tracker by agency and month, the deficits and the decisions on one page for the ballot campaigns and the legislatures of 2026 and 2027.
Already there
Agency budget documents, local reporters at the Inquirer and Billy Penn, advocates such as SPUR, state legislatures. No rider-side reader, no cross-agency tracker.
Score
Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 2 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2
Wheelchair repair: the clock on a broken chair
People whose wheelchair is their mobility, the suppliers who hold the parts and the authorizations, and the independent shops and family members who could fix it if they were allowed to.
Why now
Wheelchair right-to-repair laws are in force in Colorado, Oregon (effective 1 January 2026), Washington, Connecticut, and Texas, and New York's Senate passed its Consumer Wheelchair Repair bill in June 2026. Users told reporters in July 2026 that a lack of competition in the repair market leaves them waiting weeks; suppliers' own reports put median repair times between 28 and 63 days. A chair out of service for a month is a month without work, school, or the grocery store. The laws aim to open repair to users and independent shops, and no one yet measures whether repairs got faster.
Plays
- A repair log by supplier, state, and month: date reported, date authorized, date fixed, part involved, pooled with consent into an outcome commons that tests whether the laws work.
- A parts, tools, and manuals finder configured by state law, so a user or an independent shop knows what they are now entitled to and how to ask.
- A prior-authorization and repair-request kit: the insurer's letter in, the clock and the appeal out, in the insurer's own wording.
Already there
State legislatures and the disability advocates who passed the laws, including New York Senator Patricia Fahy's sponsorship; public radio reporting; the suppliers' internal data. No independent log exists.
Score
Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 2 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2
Accessible taxis, ride-hail, and robotaxis: the vehicle that comes on request
Wheelchair users who need a ride now, the drivers of accessible vehicles, and the cities writing rules for fleets with no drivers at all.
Why now
New York City requires every taxi placed in service since 18 October 2024 to be wheelchair accessible, requires high-volume ride-hail companies either to send a quarter of trips to accessible vehicles or to meet wait-time standards, and adopted updated wait-time rules on 29 January 2025. Waymo offers no wheelchair-accessible vehicle in its driverless fleet and has given no timeline for one; its accessible rides in San Francisco and Los Angeles have human drivers. Nevada law requires driverless companies to provide an accessible vehicle on request, and a disability advocate said in September 2026 that Waymo's Nevada rollout violates it. The alternative is running. May Mobility and Via launched wheelchair-accessible autonomous Toyota Siennas, converted by BraunAbility, in Grand Rapids, Minnesota, announced as five vehicles serving a 17-square-mile area, bookable by app or by calling 211. Disability press describes it as the only wheelchair-accessible autonomous ride service in the country.
Plays
- A wait-time commons for accessible vehicles by city and month, from riders' logs and from the data cities already require, so a robotaxi permit comes with a public number.
- Model ordinance language, versioned by city, that requires accessible service on request and publication of the wait-time data.
- The rider-owned access profile from P4, honored by any operator the city permits.
Already there
New York's Taxi and Limousine Commission and its annual accessibility reports; May Mobility, Via, and BraunAbility; Nevada's statute; the disability advocates filing complaints. No cross-city data.
Score
Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 2 · Three questions 1 · Fit 2
The ride to school: the bus that does not come
Students with disabilities and their families, the aides who ride with them, the drivers in short supply, and the districts cutting routes.
Why now
In a 2025 Associated Press-NORC (AP-NORC) survey, 81 percent of school administrators said bus driver shortages are a problem in their district, 46 percent called it a major problem, and 26 percent had cut or shortened routes. A 2025 industry survey found 17 percent of districts with a severe shortage and average driver pay of $23.18 an hour, up only 1 percent in a year. The burden falls on students with disabilities. In New York City, special education buses accounted for 74 percent of delays in 2024-25, nearly a third of rides ran over an hour, and the first weeks of 2025-26 brought 4,476 no-shows and 8,068 delays and breakdowns. Advocates say a child who arrives late every day is being denied an education.
Plays
- A family-side bus log that pools, with consent, into a commons by district, route, and month, so a chronic miss is visible to the board and the state.
- A rights and records kit for families: what the district owes, how to document, whom to write, in the district's own wording.
- A care circle around the ride, so the parent, the aide, and the school see the same bus and the same delay in real time.
Already there
Advocates for Children of New York, local reporters, district transportation offices, routing vendors. The family's record is scattered across text messages.
Score
Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 2 · Three questions 2 · Fit 1
The curb: loading, parking, and charging for everyone
Delivery drivers, paratransit drivers looking for a place to stop, residents who need an accessible space, and drivers of electric vehicles who use a wheelchair.
Why now
The Open Mobility Foundation's Curb Data Specification lets a city publish its curb rules in a machine-readable form. Seattle is converting its North Downtown curb data to it under a federal Strengthening Mobility and Revolutionizing Transportation (SMART) grant, with a public feed for commercial delivery drivers, and Boston's Curb Lab is piloting it across four areas including resident accessibility, with a public curb regulation map and resident loading-zone pilots. The U.S. Access Board published its first proposed rule on accessible electric vehicle charging in September 2024; until a final rule, its design recommendations are advisory.
Plays
- Accessible loading and pickup as a first-class curb use in the specification, so a paratransit van or an accessible taxi has a published place to stop.
- A small-city cohort to publish curb rules in the specification without a consultant.
Already there
Open Mobility Foundation, Seattle DOT, Boston's Curb Lab, the Access Board. Crowded with vendors; enter only to carry the accessibility use case.
Score
Shared layer 1 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 1 · Fit 2
Every territory on this map has a wrong turn with the same shape. The dispatcher knows which rider needs a lift and which driver she trusts with him, and that knowledge is the service. The default pitch replaces her with an optimizer and calls the lost knowledge efficiency. The pattern worth building drafts her manifests, files her state reports, and reads the eligibility letters, so she has the morning for the phone. The same goes for the volunteer coordinator, the school bus router, and the repair technician. Remove the paperwork. Keep the person whose judgment the rider depends on.
A Wednesday, when the technology is pointed at the right target
At seven a dispatcher in a county of 30,000 reviews a manifest drafted overnight and spends the first hour calling three riders whose trips changed. One of them is a man of 79 going to dialysis; his daughter two states away sees the van's window on her phone. The van arrives inside the window, and the rider taps once to log it. Across town a woman photographs a letter saying her paratransit eligibility is conditional. The reader explains what conditional means, which trips the bus will do, and how and by when to appeal, then drafts the appeal in the agency's words. On a side street two residents label the last missing ramps on their block, and the city's plan shows that this corner was promised in 2019. A volunteer driver takes a neighbor to the eye doctor and waits through the appointment, because scheduling and mileage filed themselves. At the clinic, a Medicaid ride does not come; the no-show is logged once and joins 212 others in the county that month on a page the state must answer. In the evening a council reads one page on what the budget will do to Route 14 and the vans that follow it, and votes knowing. Nobody in this day needed less technology. They needed it to be for them.
Signs we are getting there
- Every agency with more than a million demand-response trips a year publishes monthly on-time, missed-trip, and hold-time figures in one shared format, and a rider can compare two cities on one page.
- A paratransit applicant can read a decision letter and name the 21-day clock, the kind of eligibility granted, and the appeal step without calling anyone.
- City transition plans list each missing curb ramp with a date, and residents can see which were built, starting with the cities over 50,000 whose web accessibility deadline arrives in April 2027.
- In states with wheelchair right-to-repair laws, median repair times fall below two weeks by the suppliers' own reports, and an independent log agrees.
- Every city that permits a driverless fleet has a wheelchair-accessible ride available on request, measured by wait time and published monthly.
Three sizes of first step
A weekend
- Label your neighborhood's curb ramps and sidewalks in Project Sidewalk, then read your city's transition plan and write down what it promised for your block (P3).
- Log your own paratransit or Medicaid rides for a month, promised window and actual arrival, identifiers removed, as a first test set for the trip log (P1, P6).
- Photograph the entrances of ten places you use and add them to Wheelmap, so the venue layer grows by one street (P4).
- Read your transit agency's current budget and list every route that changes, with dates, in plain language, and post it where riders will see it (P8).
A season
- With one center for independent living, log 500 paratransit trips across one agency and publish the first monthly page of missed trips and hold times (P1).
- With one small city's public works department, convert its curb ramp inventory to the OpenSidewalks schema and publish promised versus built for one year (P3).
- With one state RTAP program, get five rural agencies publishing GTFS-Flex feeds and a county rides page that works by phone (P5).
- With one disability rights group in a right-to-repair state, log 200 wheelchair repairs by supplier and publish the median wait (P9).
A career
- Convene the paratransit performance data standard with three large agencies, National RTAP, and the stewards of GTFS, and carry it to the Federal Transit Administration as the reporting format it has lacked since 2007 (P1, P5).
- Found the member-owned cooperative that holds riders' trip records and access profiles and returns the value to the riders, starting with one metropolitan area (P1, P4, P10).
- Lead a state demand-response interoperability program that funds small dispatch tools to adopt shared formats and ties state grants to publishing them (P5).
- Run the observatory that puts missed Medicaid rides, school bus no-shows, and wheelchair repair times by county in front of legislators every quarter (P6, P9, P11).
Who is already doing it
- Sozialhelden runs Wheelmap and accessibility.cloud, the largest open aggregation of place accessibility data, in the A11yJSON format.
- The Taskar Center for Accessible Technology at the University of Washington leads OpenSidewalks and the Transportation Data Equity Initiative under USDOT's ITS4US program.
- Project Sidewalk, from the University of Washington's Makeability Lab, crowd-labels sidewalk barriers in 35 cities and gives the data away.
- National RTAP supports rural and tribal agencies and hosts the working group on demand-response data standards.
- ITNAmerica and America's Volunteer Driver Center recruit and support volunteer drivers for nonprofit transportation providers nationwide.
- The National Aging and Disability Transportation Center, run by Easterseals and USAging with Federal Transit Administration funding, documents volunteer and rural programs.
- The MTA publishes Access-A-Ride on-time performance and ridership as open data back to 2016, the longest public paratransit record in the country.
- The Open Mobility Foundation maintains the Curb Data Specification that Seattle and Boston are adopting.
- May Mobility, Via, and BraunAbility run the wheelchair-accessible autonomous shuttle service in Grand Rapids, Minnesota, the only one of its kind in the country according to disability press.
- The Governors Highway Safety Association publishes the state-by-state pedestrian fatality counts that let cities see whether their streets are getting safer.
Twelve territories on one page
Score key: SL shared layer nobody owns, BD buyer or deadline, OD outcome data accrues, 3Q the three questions, FT fit for a builder who convenes. Each is scored 0 to 2, so the total is out of 10.
| Code | Territory | Shared layer | Buyer or deadline | Outcome data | Three questions | Fit | Total | Horizon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 | Paratransit quality by agency and month | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 10 | Now, with one agency and one center for independent living |
| P2 | The eligibility file | 2 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 9 | 2027, inside the Kit |
| P3 | Sidewalks, curb ramps, and the plan | 2 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 9 | 2027 with Project Sidewalk and OpenSidewalks |
| P4 | Venue and station data, one rider-owned profile | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 9 | Before April 2027 |
| P8 | Transit money, legible by agency | 2 | 2 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 9 | Before the November 2026 ballots |
| P9 | Wheelchair repair clock | 2 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 9 | 2027 in the five law states |
| P5 | Demand-response data standards | 2 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 8 | 2027 cohort with one state |
| P6 | Medicaid rides and the record | 2 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 8 | 2027 with one state's riders |
| P10 | Accessible taxis, ride-hail, robotaxis | 2 | 1 | 2 | 1 | 2 | 8 | 2027 as permits are written |
| P11 | The ride to school | 2 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 8 | 2027 with one district's families |
| P7 | Volunteer drivers | 2 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 1 | 7 | 2028 |
| P12 | The curb | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 6 | Only to carry the accessibility use case |
Six plays to pursue first, and five to decline
- Paratransit quality, visible by agency and month (P1). The clearest slow-harm-made-visible play in the catalog. The data does not exist, riders can produce it, and agencies already report it to their boards. Start with one agency and one center for independent living this year.
- The eligibility file (P2). Letter-shaped, with a 21-day clock and an appeal, in every agency's own wording. It belongs inside the Kit beside the benefit notices.
- Sidewalks and the plan the city wrote (P3). PROWAG is in force for transit stops, cities are rewriting plans, and Project Sidewalk proved residents will label. Build the plan reader and the promised-versus-built record.
- Transit money, legible by agency (P8). Three of the largest regions hit cliffs in 2025 and 2026 and voters decide in November 2026. Give riders and councils a reader before the votes.
- The wheelchair repair clock (P9). Five states have laws and nobody measures whether they work. A repair log is cheap, consented, and legislative.
- One profile the rider owns (P4). The portability lever for everything else, offered to cities and operators facing the 2027 and 2028 deadlines.
Assumptions and limits. Scores are judgments. Paratransit figures are self-reported by agencies and are not comparable across them, which is the point of P1; the APTA Fact Book totals cover the latest reported year in that edition and include all demand-response service, not only ADA complementary paratransit. Microtransit cost comparisons come from a union report and from press summaries of agency pilots, and should be read as such. The statement that complementary paratransit is defined around fixed routes is from the ADA regulation and was not re-verified in this pass; the three-quarter-mile figure is therefore omitted. Wheelchair repair times are supplier-reported, as cited in 2026 coverage. The Wisconsin broker figures are from a 2014 audit and the MACPAC spending figure is from fiscal 2018; no newer national NEMT data appeared in this pass. The claim that there are more demand-responsive routes than fixed routes comes from a scheduling software vendor. The count of volunteer driver programs is from the National Aging and Disability Transportation Center. The accessibility.cloud place count is as stated by Sozialhelden. Research for this chapter used 36 successful web searches before the session's search budget ran out; three further searches and one direct page fetch failed. Those failed lookups would have confirmed the paratransit service-area rule, the Federal Transit Administration's capacity-constraint regulation, and ITNAmerica's ride counts, so none of those figures appear here. Also left out as unreliable or unverifiable in this pass: a claim about the number of states with microtransit subsidy programs, a widely repeated per-ride cost for one city's cancelled microtransit pilot, the exact dimensions in the Access Board's charging-station recommendations, and per-trip costs for Massachusetts's Medicaid broker service. Facts were checked through 4 October 2026. A 5 October spot-check used search results because source pages could not be opened, and could not confirm APTA's demand-response cost figures, Access-A-Ride's exact on-time rate, MetroAccess's November miss rate, or the 21-day rule's text, so those are approximate or attributed.
- Paratransit scale and reporting: APTA 2025 Public Transportation Fact Book; APTA on ridership recovery by mode, May 2025; FTA ADA paratransit compliance assessment, Cleveland, 2002
- Agency performance: MTA on Access-A-Ride, first half of 2025; MTA on the October 2025 ridership record; Access-A-Ride drop-off on-time performance open data; WMATA MetroAccess performance report, November 2025; NYC Comptroller audit of Access-A-Ride oversight; Alexandria paratransit cost per trip, FY2024
- Eligibility: RTA Chicago ADA paratransit brochure; MassDOT on ADA paratransit and The RIDE; High Point eligibility assessment RFP; UTA eligibility brochure; Advance Transit on the 21-day rule
- Web accessibility deadlines: EDUCAUSE on the DOJ Title II deadlines
- Sidewalks and PROWAG: Access Board on DOT's adoption of PROWAG; Federal Register, 18 December 2024; Illinois DOT ADA initiative; Carson City transition plan inventory; PacTrans on Project Sidewalk, April 2025; OpenSidewalks; TDEI on data.gov; ITS4US Washington deployment
- Street safety: GHSA on 2025 pedestrian deaths; GHSA first-half 2025 data; NHTSA Traffic Safety Facts, bicyclists, 2024 data
- Venue and station data: Sozialhelden on accessibility.cloud; GTFS pathways and physical accessibility; GTFS-Realtime service alerts recommendations; UnlockedMaps; CTA elevator alerts; Taskar Center GTFS-Pathways webinar
- Demand-response standards: GTFS-Flex adopted into GTFS; GTFS-Flex specification; National RTAP report on demand-response data; National RTAP DRT data specifications working group; Advancing Rural Mobility Program, Michigan pilot; Arizona DOT GTFS-Flex guidance
- Microtransit: ATU, The False Promise of Microtransit; Streetsblog on the ATU report; Human Transit on microtransit evidence
- Rural access: High Plains Public Radio on rural grocery distance
- Medicaid rides: Healthcare Dive on Modivcare's bankruptcy; Maine Public on the filing; Massachusetts State Auditor, MassHealth transportation, May 2025; KFF Health News, Left Behind; Wisconsin audit coverage; Colorado Newsline on state oversight; MACPAC mandated report on NEMT; CTAA research summary
- Volunteer drivers: ITNAmerica 2025 annual report; America's Volunteer Driver Center; NADTC rural volunteer programs; National RTAP Volunteer Driver Toolkit; Volunteer Driver Tax Appreciation Act reintroduction; National Council of Nonprofits on volunteer mileage
- Transit finances: Inquirer on SEPTA's budget; Billy Penn on the August 2025 cuts; $394 million capital flex; CBS Chicago on the RTA gap; Capitol News Illinois on SB 2111; SFCTA on the Bay Area cliff; CBS on SB 63's signing; Caltrain on the ballot measure
- Wheelchair repair: WUNC on repair wait times, July 2026; New York Senate on the Consumer Wheelchair Repair bill
- Taxis, ride-hail, robotaxis: NYC rule on 100 percent accessible taxis; TLC wait-time rule; TLC accessibility report 2024; MDA Quest on WAV requirements; Streetsblog on Waymo in Nevada, September 2026; Nevada Current; Waymo on wheelchair-accessible vehicles; TechCrunch on May Mobility's accessible shuttles; Smart Cities Dive on May Mobility
- School transportation: AP-NORC 2025 State of School Transportation; School Bus Fleet 2025 district survey; Advocates for Children on New York bus delays; Planetizen on the driver shortage
- Curb and charging: Seattle SMART grant curb project; Boston Curb Lab; Electrification Coalition on accessible charging guidelines; Joint Office on charging accessibility
- History: University of Washington on Section 504; disAbility Law Center of Virginia on ADA history