Skip to Fulmerica links
Worth Building · Chapter 84 October 2026A draft for public use

Civic Life and Local News

Local government is where decisions that change a street, a school, or a rent check get made, and it has the least coverage and the thinnest staff. The default path hands the neighborhood a personalized feed, an outrage cycle, and a petition nobody has to answer. This chapter applies the catalog's questions to local news, public meetings, small governments, and the tools neighbors use to deliberate, then maps eleven territories with current facts, plays, and scores.

01The idea, in civic life

Decisions made legible, and neighbors who can act on them

In the evening, neighbors who understand exactly what the zoning proposal says walk into a public meeting knowing what is at stake and how to be heard.

In civic life the things that protect people have plain names. The reporter at the back of the room. The neighbor who reads the agenda. The clerk who keeps the minutes. Each is thinning out. In 2025, 213 counties had no local news source and 1,524 had exactly one. None of this needs less technology to repair. It needs transcription, summarization, and paperwork pointed at the room where decisions are made, with the people still in it.

SceneThe default pathWhat we could build instead
The zoning noticeA legal ad in small type; a feed post saying the neighborhood is under attack; three people at the hearing.The notice is read into plain words with the parcel, the change, the date, and how to be heard; twenty neighbors arrive knowing what they want.
The council meetingNobody attends, nobody reports, and the minutes appear six weeks later as three lines.A trained resident attends and annotates; the recording is transcribed that night; decisions and due dates go into a public ledger anyone can search.
Public commentA bot calls in; an agency sorts a million comments by sentiment; nobody can tell which ones were people.Comments carry a resident's name and a note on what help they had; the published synthesis links every theme back to the comments beneath it.
The town budgetA 300-page PDF, a hearing on a Tuesday afternoon, and a tax bill in the mail.The budget is shown as changes with dates; residents see which lines rose and fell over five years and can respond in a form the finance director can use.
The small town's grantThe clerk who is also the treasurer misses the deadline; the money goes to the city with a grants office.A notice reader and a deadline engine run for the town; the clerk decides; the application is in the funder's own wording.
The news desertOne reporter covers four counties and a social media group fills the rest.A shared civic desk handles records requests, transcripts, and data, so the reporter's time goes to people and the record exists even where no reporter does.
02Seven commitments, seven examples

What each commitment means at the council table

CommitmentIn civic life, it meansA concrete instance
1 · Judge by what happens to peopleA civic tool succeeds when more residents understand a decision before it is made and more promises are kept afterward.Warren County, Kentucky measured its 2025 online conversation by participation, with 7,890 residents, and then adopted a strategic plan in April 2026 that can be checked against their ideas.
2 · Keep people in chargeRecords are legible; a human makes every irreversible call; residents and towns can export everything.Metagov's deliberation-tool teams agreed on exportable flat files, so a town can leave a platform with its whole conversation intact.
3 · Build capability rather than dependenceA resident who uses the tool once can read the next notice alone; a new clerk or election official learns the job faster.A 2025 University of Florida study found Documenters' meeting notes make local governance more readable to residents; a notice reader that explains why a hearing matters does the same work.
4 · Make slow harm visibleSurface news closures, budget lines, staff turnover, and records response times before they become normal.News-desert counties rose from about 150 twenty years ago to 213 in 2025. Local election official turnover reached 41 percent in 2024. Few residents have seen either plotted for their own county.
5 · Design for groupsThe block club, the neighborhood association, the food policy council, and the town itself are the users.One shared position from an association reaches the public record, with every member able to see it, edit it, and leave.
6 · Keep the effort that builds relationshipsRemove transcription, minutes, filing, and reminders; keep attendance, speaking, listening, and the walk to the meeting.Clerks using transcription tools report minutes dropping from four to eight hours a meeting to under an hour. The saved hours belong at the counter with residents.
7 · Name pace and direction as choicesNews deserts, bot comments, and vendor lock-in are decisions someone made. Point to documenters, civic assemblies, and open formats as alternatives that work.Press Forward moved 400 million dollars to local news in two years and seeded 41 chapters in 31 states. The direction of local news is being chosen right now.

The three questions, applied

ThingMore capable or more dependent?Closer to each other or to the system?See, steer, and leave?
A personalized neighborhood feedDependent; the ranking decides what the neighborhood is upset aboutCloser to the systemOpaque ranking; the group cannot be exported
An online petitionSigning teaches nothing about who decidesAlone with a buttonCan leave; nothing to take along
The Documenters NetworkCapable; residents learn how a board works and are paid to watch itCloser to each other and to the roomNotes are public; anyone can stop
Warren County's Polis conversation with a published synthesisCapable; 7,890 residents saw where they agreedCloser to each other across dividesMostly; the synthesis is public, the summarizer is a vendor's
A lottery-selected civic assembly (Fort Collins, 2025)Capable; 20 residents learned a 165-acre decision inside outCloser; strangers deliberated face to faceFully; the recommendations went to the voters in November 2025
An AI-generated call to public comment (Austin, 2024)Dependent; nobody learned anythingDisplaces real speakersNobody can see who sent it
03Where to push

Five places to push in local civic life

Place to pushWhat it meansIn civic life
ParadigmTechnology as a meansCivic technology exists to make the room where decisions happen more legible and more crowded with informed neighbors. Engagement counts are a side effect.
Goals and metricsCapability, trust, connectionResidents who can explain a decision before it is made; promises kept by the date promised; meetings documented; records requests answered on time; groups that still meet a year later.
Information flowsMake slow harm visibleWhere news sources disappear, how long records take, which budget lines creep, which recommendations were ignored, which officials left. Little of this is measured below the state level.
RulesLegibility, portability, interoperability, exitOpen meetings laws that require recordings with minutes, as Vermont's Act 51 has since June 2025; web accessibility deadlines in April 2027 and April 2028; shared formats for deliberation records; a town's right to export its data from any vendor.
Self-organizationWho can act togetherNeighborhood associations, documenter corps, mutual aid groups, food policy councils, member-owned newsrooms, and coalitions of small towns that buy software together.
Why civic life, specifically

Local government is the one domain where decisions are already required to be made in public. Every state has an open meetings law and a public records law. The notice, the hearing, the minutes, and the vote are legible in principle. What has thinned is the capacity around them, meaning the reporter, the records staff, and the neighbors who knew the agenda. Twenty years ago about 150 counties were news deserts; in 2025 the count was 213. The precedents this catalog leans on fit here too. The town meeting is an old cooperative institution, and the Documenters model has shown in about 20 communities that paying residents to watch their own government works. The task is to add transcription, summarization, and paperwork to those institutions without removing the people from them.

04The map

Eleven civic territories

Scored on the catalog's five-part rubric. Each card names which of the nine reusable parts it uses.

How to read a card: its score adds five judgments, each from 0 to 2 (shared layer nobody owns, buyer or deadline, outcome data, the three questions, fit), for a total out of 10.

V1Score 10 of 10Reuses: outcome commons, place config, standards cohort

The meeting record: a documenter in the room, a transcript the same night

Residents, clerks, and one-person newsrooms in the 1,524 counties with a single news source and the 213 with none.

Why now

In 2025 the Documenters Network published 3,253 public meeting assignments, added four sites, in Columbia Gorge, Tulsa, Kansas City, and Columbus, ran 422 workshops, and passed 5,600 members. The MacArthur Foundation counts more than 5,000 people trained across about 20 communities. Trade coverage in 2026 puts the ClerkMinutes transcription tool in more than 450 municipalities, with minutes cut from four to eight hours a meeting to 30 to 60 minutes. Vermont's Act 51, in force since 9 June 2025, requires recordings to be posted when minutes are.

Plays

  • An open meeting record: agenda, transcript, motions, votes, and promises with dates, as an exportable flat file in the Metagov pattern, adopted by documenter sites and clerk tools alike.
  • Documenter plus model: the resident attends and annotates, the model transcribes and timestamps, and both are published together with the human note on top.
  • A decisions ledger per town, by month, showing what was promised and when it was due. This is the outcome commons for local government.

Already there

City Bureau's Documenters Network and Documenters.org; ClerkMinutes, Hamlet, Granicus, and CivicPlus on the clerk side; the Illinois Municipal League's fact sheet on preparing minutes with AI. No shared format joins the resident's notes to the clerk's transcript.

Score

Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 2 · Outcome data 2 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2

V2Score 8 of 10Reuses: records pipeline, outcome commons, member-owned data

News deserts and the shared desk behind the last reporter

About 50 million Americans with limited or no local news, the nearly 400 nonprofit newsrooms, and the more than 200 Report for America corps members expected in newsrooms by July 2026.

Why now

Medill's 2025 report counts 213 news-desert counties, up from 206, and 1,524 counties with one source; 136 newspapers closed in the year, while more than 300 local news startups launched over five years, 80 percent of them digital-only. Press Forward had moved $400 million through 110 funders by October 2025, with 41 chapters in 31 states. The 2025 INN (Institute for Nonprofit News) Index puts the median nonprofit newsroom at $532,000 in revenue. Report for America expects more than 200 corps members in newsrooms by July 2026 across more than 175 host newsrooms.

Plays

  • A shared civic desk for small newsrooms: records requests, meeting transcripts from V1, and budget and zoning data, drafted by models and edited by the reporter, so reporting hours go to people.
  • A county civic information index, published yearly, measuring whether meeting records, budgets, and notices can be found, so the loss is visible before the last outlet closes.
  • Member-owned local news: a cooperative that holds the archive and the subscriber list, so the record outlives any one outlet.

Already there

Press Forward and its chapters, the Institute for Nonprofit News, Report for America, the Documenters Network. The shared desk and the index do not exist.

Score

Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 2 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 2 · Fit 1

V3Score 9 of 10Reuses: notice reader, place config, deadline engine

The notice before the vote: zoning, budgets, and transition plans in plain words

Neighbors holding a legal notice they cannot parse, planning commissioners in 7,090 mapped jurisdictions, and finance directors defending a 300-page budget.

Why now

The National Zoning Atlas has analyzed more than 76,500 zoning districts in more than 7,090 jurisdictions from more than 800,500 pages of code, with work under way in about 36 states. Kerrville, Texas launched an online budget simulation in July 2024 for its 2025 budget. The Department of Transportation adopted the Public Right-of-Way Accessibility Guidelines for transit stops effective 17 January 2025; the guidelines set national standards for sidewalks, curb ramps, crosswalks, and signals that transition plans will be measured against.

Plays

  • A notice reader for hearings: the letter or legal ad goes in; the parcel, the change, who decides, the date, and how to be heard come out, in the household's language, with a pointer to the code section.
  • A budget as changes: every line against five prior years, with the drift sentence written for the resident and a comment form that lands in the finance director's format.
  • A transition plan tracker: what the town promised to fix, by what date, and whether it did, for accessibility and for climate and energy transition plans.

Already there

National Zoning Atlas; Balancing Act, used in Kerrville; Granicus and CivicPlus agendas. Nobody reads the notice for the neighbor.

Score

Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 2 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2

V4Score 7 of 10Reuses: standards cohort, evidence file

Public comment under automation

Councils and clerks who must hear everyone, agencies with tens of thousands of comments, and residents whose three minutes a bot can take.

Why now

On 7 November 2024 an AI-generated caller held Austin City Council's public comment line for more than three minutes with inflammatory remarks; Mayor Kirk Watson ordered a review, and the clerk's office ruled out pre-screening or editing speakers. An April 2026 op-ed in Santa Monica described AI already present in that council's letters, comments, and phone lines. Federally, the Centers for Disease Control uses a generative model to sort comments as for, against, or neutral; the Department of Transportation uses agentic AI to categorize them; and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), which received more than 44,000 comments on digital asset rules and more than 29,000 on the clean hydrogen credit, some written with AI, is weighing AI to read them, according to the Government Accountability Office.

Plays

  • A comment with provenance: the resident signs, says what help they had, and that disclosure travels with the comment into the record; councils can give signed resident comments their time first.
  • Open synthesis: when a body summarizes comments by machine, it publishes the summary with every theme linked to its comments, so a resident can check whether their point survived.
  • A comment record format shared by clerk tools and deliberation tools, so a hearing's comments can be exported and studied.

Already there

Granicus and PublicInput on the clerk side; Polis and Sensemaker for synthesis; the American Bar Association's 2026 review of agency practice. The provenance layer does not exist.

Score

Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 1 · Fit 2

V5Score 9 of 10Reuses: standards cohort, outcome commons, place config

Deliberation at the scale of a county, accountable afterward

Towns and counties that want more than a hearing, residents chosen by lottery or gathered online, and the 30-plus deliberation tool teams converging on shared formats.

Why now

In 33 days in early 2025, 7,890 residents of Warren County, Kentucky shared about 3,940 ideas and cast more than a million votes on Polis; Jigsaw's Sensemaker summarized them into 12 topics and 70 subtopics, and the county adopted its BG2050 strategic plan on 30 April 2026. Fort Collins, Colorado convened 20 residents from 15,000 invited households in spring 2025 on a 165-acre site; voters approved the resulting ordinance in November 2025. Deschutes County, Oregon gathered 30 residents in 2024 and produced 23 recommendations with at least 75 percent support. Culver City, California's first assembly in 2026 put 60 residents and 1,500 hours into 42 recommendations on budget participation, with a public response due 28 September 2026. Metagov used a $400,000 Mina Foundation grant to bring 21 tool teams to interoperability on flat files; the Government of Scotland adopted the standards for its national engagement platform with about $1 million committed, and more than 30 teams are expected by 2026.

Plays

  • The accountability ledger: every assembly or Polis recommendation with the body's response and date, tracked publicly for three years.
  • A lottery and logistics kit for towns under 50,000: stratified selection, honoraria such as Culver City's $675, childcare, and scheduling, with the deliberation left to the people.
  • The standards cohort, continued: fund small tools to adopt the shared record, then win state and county buyers.

Already there

The Computational Democracy Project (Polis), Jigsaw (Sensemaker), Metagov, and the city teams in Fort Collins, Culver City, and Deschutes County. The ledger does not exist.

Score

Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 2 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2

V6Score 8 of 10Reuses: notice reader, deadline engine, place config

Small governments and the paperwork that eats them

The 77 percent of localities in one federal grant bootcamp with fewer than 50,000 residents, and the 42 percent with fewer than 10,000, where the clerk is also the treasurer and the web manager.

Why now

Of nearly 700 localities in that bootcamp, 77 percent were under 50,000 and 42 percent under 10,000; the Local Infrastructure Hub has coached more than 1,200 municipalities into over $700 million in federal funds. The Department of Justice's web accessibility rule now binds governments of 50,000 or more by 26 April 2027 and smaller governments and special districts by 26 April 2028, at Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 AA. The GovAI Coalition, formed by San José in November 2023, passed 3,000 members and became a nonprofit by April 2026, with members from Los Angeles to Nederland, Colorado, population 1,500. A Massachusetts bill would require permanent hybrid meetings and create a trust fund to help towns pay for the technology.

Plays

  • A shared back office owned by the towns: grant notices read, deadlines kept, applications drafted in the funder's wording, decided by the clerk and the board.
  • Accessible by default: agendas, minutes, and notices published from a shared template that meets the 2027 and 2028 rule, so a town of 3,000 does not hire a consultant.
  • Place configuration for every state's open meetings law, so a tool knows what Vermont requires and what Texas does.

Already there

The National League of Cities and the Local Infrastructure Hub, the GovAI Coalition, state municipal leagues, CivicPlus. A town-owned back office does not exist.

Score

Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 2 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 1 · Fit 2

V7Score 8 of 10Reuses: records pipeline, deadline engine, outcome commons

Records requests as a pipeline with a clock

Residents, documenters, and reporters who ask; clerks and records officers who answer; and everyone waiting in between.

Why now

Federal agencies processed about 1.6 million requests in fiscal 2025 and released records in full or part 47 percent of the time, the lowest rate since at least 2010, with a backlog near 340,000 on 30 September 2025. Across MuckRock's more than 36,000 requests, the average response is 285 days and 26.6 percent succeed. Local response times are not aggregated anywhere.

Plays

  • Request letters in each state's statutory wording, with that state's clock, reminders, and appeal templates.
  • A response-time commons by agency and month, built from consented request logs, so slow drift at a county becomes a fact a council can see.
  • Proactive disclosure lists: the ten records a town is asked for most, published before anyone asks.

Already there

MuckRock, state coalitions for open government, Sunshine Week. The local commons is open.

Score

Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2

V8Score 6 of 10Reuses: care circle, notice reader

The library as the civic front desk

About 9,000 public library systems with more than 17,000 outlets, their digital navigators, and the residents who bring a government letter to the desk.

Why now

Executive Order 14238 of 14 March 2025 ordered the Institute of Museum and Library Services reduced to the extent the law allows; its 2024 budget was $266.7 million, Library Services and Technology Act grants were terminated effective 1 April 2025, and about 70 staff were placed on leave. Digital navigator programs appear in 39 state and territory digital equity plans and run in hundreds of communities. The notices in V3 and the web accessibility deadlines in V6 all land on the same desk.

Plays

  • The civic help desk: the notice reader, the comment kit, and the meeting record installed where a navigator can sit beside someone and teach it once.
  • A care circle for the resident dealing with the town: a family member, a navigator, and a neighbor, with permissions the resident controls and can revoke.
  • Counting civic help: what libraries did for residents with government, by month, for the state budget hearing.

Already there

Urban Libraries Council, the National Digital Inclusion Alliance, state libraries. The civic desk is informal everywhere and documented nowhere.

Score

Shared layer 1 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 2 · Fit 1

V9Score 6 of 10Reuses: place config, evidence file

Election offices that lose two in five of their people

Local election officials in thousands of jurisdictions, the poll workers they train, and the voters of the November 2026 midterms.

Why now

Turnover among local election officials reached 41 percent in 2024, the highest in at least 25 years; two in five of the officials who ran the 2020 election had left before 2024, according to the Bipartisan Policy Center, reported in August 2025. In the Brennan Center's 2025 survey, 38 percent reported threats, harassment, or abuse, 63 percent of those in person; 59 percent worry about political interference; 62 percent were concerned about losing federal cybersecurity support; 80 percent said federal funding should stay the same or rise; one in five had a budget request denied.

Plays

  • A handover kit for new officials: each state's procedures and calendar as place configuration, with plain explanations of why each step exists.
  • Public explainers of counting and certification timelines, posted by the office in advance, so a delay reads as planned rather than suspicious.
  • A capacity log: staffing, budget requests, and denials by county, consented and aggregated, for state legislatures.

Already there

Bipartisan Policy Center, Brennan Center for Justice, Center for Tech and Civic Life, Institute for Responsive Government. The work must be led by officials themselves.

Score

Shared layer 1 · Buyer or deadline 2 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 1 · Fit 1

V10Score 6 of 10Reuses: care circle, member-owned data

Neighborhood associations, mutual aid, and the groups that never add up

Block clubs, neighborhood associations, mutual aid groups, food policy councils, and the former civic tech brigades, each too small to buy software and together a movement.

Why now

A 2023 census counted 358 food policy councils and state networks. The Mutual Aid Hub had mapped more than 1,000 groups by 2021. Code for America ended its Brigade program in 2023, cutting loose about 60 chapters; some, such as Open Kentuckiana, regrouped independently. This is the fifth cause of failed scale, F5, in which small groups never aggregate into a market or a program.

Plays

  • A group operating system the group owns: roles, permissions, minutes, money, and the right to remove anyone and to leave with the data.
  • The meeting record and the notice reader from V1 and V3 offered to associations, so a block's position reaches the council record with every member's name on it.
  • Federation without a landlord: shared formats so a council of neighborhoods can act like a city department when it needs to.

Already there

Mutual Aid Hub, the Food Policy Networks project at Johns Hopkins, former brigades such as Open Kentuckiana, neighborhood coalitions. Tooling is borrowed from workplaces and owned by vendors.

Score

Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 0 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 2 · Fit 1

V11Score 8 of 10Reuses: outcome commons, standards cohort, deadline engine

Participatory budgeting and the promise with a date

Residents who vote on a share of a budget, the offices that run the process, and the public works crews who build the winners.

Why now

At least 64 cities and counties, 258 districts or wards, and more than 260 schools in the United States have run participatory budgeting, allocating more than $360 million, by the Participatory Budgeting Project's tally. New York City's The People's Money runs every year and is open to residents aged 11 and older. Boston's Office of Participatory Budgeting published its fiscal 2027 cycle in June 2026. Culver City's 2026 assembly asked how to increase public participation in the budget and produced 42 recommendations.

Plays

  • From ballot to ribbon: every funded project tracked by month until built, with the delay explained. This is the outcome commons for the one budget residents touched directly.
  • A participatory budgeting record in the shared deliberation format, so a ward's ideas, votes, and results can move between tools and be compared across cities.
  • School and youth budgeting with the paperwork handled, so the deliberation hour is spent deliberating.

Already there

Participatory Budgeting Project, New York City's Civic Engagement Commission, Boston's office. The build tracker is missing almost everywhere.

Score

Shared layer 2 · Buyer or deadline 1 · Outcome data 1 · Three questions 2 · Fit 2

05An ordinary day

A Thursday in a town of nine thousand

The zoning notice for the lot behind the elementary school arrived on Tuesday. By Wednesday the notice reader had turned the legal ad into a page every household could read in English and Spanish, with the parcel, the change from single-family to mixed use, the planning commission date, and the three ways to be heard. The neighborhood association met in the library's back room that night. Twelve people came. A digital navigator helped Mrs. Alvarez, who is 81, pull up last month's commission transcript on the screen. A Documenter had attended, and her note said the commissioners promised a traffic study by March. The association drafted one position in forty minutes, because the arguing was about the position and the paperwork was already done.

On Thursday twenty-two neighbors walked into the hearing knowing what the proposal said. Six spoke. The clerk's recording was transcribed overnight, and by Friday morning the decisions ledger showed the vote, the condition the commission attached, and the date the study was due. The reporter who covers four towns read the ledger and spent her afternoon at the school pickup line talking to parents. In March the ledger will turn yellow if the study has not arrived, and the association already knows who will ask about it.

Signs we are getting there

  • Medill's annual count of news-desert counties stops rising, and the count of single-source counties falls for two years running.
  • Every public body in a town posts a recording and a searchable transcript within a week of the meeting, and residents cite timestamps at the next one.
  • A town's decisions ledger shows the date each promise was due and whether it was kept, and council members read from it in session.
  • Public comment records show how many speakers were verified residents, and that number rises while automated calls fall.
  • Records requests to local agencies are answered within the statutory clock in most cases, and the response-time chart sits on the agency's own site.
06Where you could start

A weekend, a season, a career

A weekend

  • Sign up with a Documenters site and attend one meeting, or where no site exists, publish your own notes in the open meeting record format (V1).
  • Map which of your county's public bodies post recordings, transcripts, and minutes, and send the gap list to your library and your nearest newsroom (V1, V2).
  • File one records request for your town's accessibility transition plan or its latest budget, in the state's statutory wording, and log the response time (V7, V3).

A season

  • With one newsroom or documenter site, transcribe every council and school board meeting for 90 days and publish a decisions ledger with due dates (V1).
  • With a town under 10,000 residents, read every grant notice it receives for 90 days and file two applications in the funder's wording, on time (V6).
  • With a planning department, run the notice reader on every hearing notice for a quarter and count attendance against the same quarter last year (V3).

A career

  • Convene the open meeting record standard across documenter sites, clerk vendors, and deliberation tools in the Metagov pattern, and win a state buyer (V1, V5).
  • Found a town-owned back office cooperative for small governments in one state, starting with grants and accessibility ahead of the April 2028 deadline (V6).
  • Lead a county civic information index and a records response-time commons that Press Forward chapters and nonprofit newsrooms can use (V2, V7).

Who is already doing it

  • City Bureau's Documenters Network. Trains and pays residents to cover public meetings; 3,253 assignments in 2025 across about 20 communities.
  • Press Forward. A coalition of more than 110 funders that moved $400 million to local news in two years and seeded 41 local chapters.
  • Report for America. Places reporters in local newsrooms; more than 200 corps members expected by July 2026 across more than 175 host newsrooms.
  • Institute for Nonprofit News. The trade body for nearly 400 nonprofit newsrooms and publisher of the annual INN Index.
  • Metagov. Convenes deliberation tool teams on interoperable formats now adopted by the Government of Scotland.
  • The Computational Democracy Project. Maintains Polis, the open-source tool Warren County, Kentucky used for 7,890 residents in 2025.
  • National Zoning Atlas. Has digitized the zoning codes of more than 7,090 jurisdictions.
  • GovAI Coalition. More than 3,000 members writing AI policy templates and vendor fact sheets for local governments.
  • MuckRock. Files and tracks public records requests, more than 36,000 to date, and publishes response times by agency.
  • Participatory Budgeting Project. Has supported budgeting processes in dozens of cities and hundreds of wards and schools.
07Scorecard

Eleven territories on one page

Score key: SL shared layer nobody owns, BD buyer or deadline, OD outcome data accrues, 3Q the three questions, FT fit for a builder who convenes. Each is scored 0 to 2, so the total is out of 10.

CodeTerritoryShared layerBuyer or deadlineOutcome dataThree questionsFitTotalHorizon
V1The meeting record2222210Now, with a Documenters site
V3The notice before the vote2212292027, with a planning department
V5Deliberation at county scale2212292027 cohort; Scotland as the first buyer
V2News deserts and the shared desk2212182027, with a Press Forward chapter
V6Small governments and paperwork2211282027, ahead of the April 2028 deadline
V7Records requests with a clock211228Now, state by state
V11Participatory budgeting tracked2112282027, with one city office
V4Public comment under automation2111272027, with one clerk's office
V8The library as civic front desk111216With a state library, 2028
V9Election office capacity121116Only led by officials
V10Associations and mutual aid2012162028, riding on V1 and V3
08Picks and declines

Six to pursue first, and five to leave alone

  1. The meeting record (V1). The clearest shared layer in the chapter. Documenters supply the people, clerk tools the transcripts, Vermont's law the first rule.
  2. The notice before the vote (V3). The orientation's own evening scene. A notice reader for hearings, built on the zoning atlas, with the budget-as-changes view beside it.
  3. Deliberation with a ledger (V5). Four cities have shown the front half works. Build the back half, the public record of what the body did with the recommendations, on Metagov's formats.
  4. Records requests with a clock (V7). Templates in each state's wording and a response-time commons. The pipeline every other territory needs.
  5. Participatory budgeting tracked to completion (V11). The one budget residents touch directly deserves a build tracker, and the data already exists in city offices.
  6. The shared desk behind the last reporter (V2). Offer V1, V3, and V7 as one back office to the newsrooms Press Forward funds, led by journalists.
Another neighborhood feed. Ranking by outrage is the default path in a new coat, whatever the model inside it.
A petition platform. It teaches nothing about who decides and leaves no record a council must answer.
AI that writes public comments at volume. It takes the three minutes from a neighbor and poisons the record for everyone, as Austin learned in 2024.
A chatbot that answers for the clerk with no record. If the answer is in the minutes or the code, link to it. If it is in neither, the town is now liable for an invention.
A sentiment dashboard offered in place of the hearing. Summaries belong beside the room. They never replace it.
SourcesChecked 4 October 2026

Assumptions and limits. Scores are judgments. The national participatory budgeting tally is the Participatory Budgeting Project's figure as repeated by the Democracy Collaborative; its data year could not be confirmed in this pass. Metagov's 2026 update reports a $400,000 Mina Foundation grant; its 2024 announcement described a first round of $200,000, so the larger figure appears to be cumulative. Warren County figures come from the county and trade press; a vendor-reported satisfaction figure was left out. The ClerkMinutes count and time savings are from trade coverage. The Mutual Aid Hub count dates from 2021. The Austin incident date is 7 November 2024, inferred from contemporaneous coverage. A 2026 Brennan Center survey could not be read in this pass, so 2025 figures are used. Counts of 311 systems, of neighborhood associations, and of local governments lacking an accessibility transition plan could not be verified and are not stated. Food policy council figures are from 2023 and Local Infrastructure Hub figures from 2022.